
It is
well-known that many species of turfgrass and trees and shrubs are quite
tolerant of recycled water. Some species of trees and shrubs, however,
are susceptible to certain attributes of recycled water, especially
after several years of exposure. The question facing us now and into the
future is not whether recycled water should be used to irrigate
landscapes, but rather how do we best manage landscapes using
recycled water?
Water quality
for trees and shrubs is important in determining whether plants will
thrive. Generally, in the context of landscape irrigation, six aspects
of water govern its quality: soluble salts (salinity), sodium,
bicarbonate, pH, nutrient elements and potentially harmful levels of
chloride.
The water
source prior to recycling is an important factor in the salinity and
concentration of other constituents that can adversely affect trees and
shrubs. Fortunately, the quality of water sources and potable water
distributed by Denver Water is very high. This is good news for trees
and shrubs since much of the recycled water will be used for irrigating
parks, golf courses and landscapes at various commercial sites.
Some
Questions from Landscape Managers
and Grounds Superintendents about
Recycled Water for Trees & Shrubs
|
Will recycled water adversely impact existing
or established landscapes?
We do not expect any adverse effects on established landscapes. To be
safe, landscape managers should use good maintenance practices and
periodically monitor plant and soil conditions. With good observation
there are practical, effective measures that can be taken to prevent or
minimize any problem.
|
|
What is salinity and how does it affect trees and shrubs?
Salinity is an
indication of the concentration of dissolved salts in irrigation water.
Salinity is the most important measure of water quality for trees and
shrubs. When excess salts are added to the soil, they can cause a
buildup of salts in and on a plants foliage. Most commonly dissolved salts
in recycled water are associated with sodium and bicarbonate.
|
|
How does sodium affect plants?
Irrigating
with water that is high in sodium can change soil structure, resulting
in poor permeability. As sodium accumulates in the soil, it attaches to
soil particles, forming a crust which impedes drainage. Poor drainage
stresses plants and depletes the soil of needed oxygen for root growth.
|
|
How does bicarbonate affect plants?
Irrigating
with water that has a high bicarbonate level can change soil structure.
Recycled water high in bicarbonate will precipitate calcium and
magnesium from soil water as the soil water or solution concentrates
through evapotranspiration. This results in a higher proportion of
sodium.
|
|
How does pH affect plants?
The pH of
irrigation water can affect the availability of nutrient elements.
Deficiencies or excesses of certain elements cause stress. For example,
consistently high pH causes an iron and/or manganese deficiency in
foliage, resulting in yellowing (chlorosis), which ultimately causes
leaves and twigs to die.
|
|
Will the nutrients in recycled water help plant growth?
Typically, the
nutrient levels in recycled water are more than adequate for trees and
shrubs. This has the added benefit of potentially reducing the need for
fertilization. Nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium and sulfur are the
nutrient elements of greatest benefit through the use of recycled water.
|
What
types of plants are most affected by recycled water?
Generally,
turfgrasses are quite tolerant of recycled water either through built-in
resistance or because turfgrass is mowed frequently, preventing salts
and toxic levels of elements from accumulating. Most annual and
perennial plants are quite tolerant because the plant dies back or is
removed at the end of the growing season, thereby preventing a buildup
of salts and toxic levels of elements in the stems and foliage.
Plants most
affected are trees, especially conifers or evergreens such as spruces,
pines and firs. Some species, such as pinon pine and upright junipers
are very tolerant. Deciduous trees are much more tolerant than conifers
because they lose their leaves each fall, thereby preventing a buildup
of harmful constituents from season to season. To a large extent, the
landscape manager or grounds superintendent must rely on observation and
experience when determining the susceptibility of plants to salts and
other potentially harmful constituents in water.
Recycled
Water Salt Tolerances for Plant Material |
| Common Name |
Salt Tolerance |
|
Deciduous trees |
| Green ash |
High |
| Honeylocust |
High |
| Plains
cottonwood |
High |
| Weeping willow |
High |
| Callery pear |
Moderate |
| Freeman maple |
Moderate |
| Golden Raintree |
Moderate |
| Norway maple |
Moderate |
| Washington hawthorn |
Moderate |
| Littleleaf
linden |
Low |
| River birch |
Low |
| Deciduous
shrubs |
| Common lilac |
High |
| Forsythia |
High |
| Potentilla |
High |
| Privet |
High |
| Rabbitbrush |
High |
| Cotoneaster |
Moderate |
| Elderberry
(elder) |
Moderate |
| Viburnum |
Moderate |
| Western sand
cherry |
Moderate |
| Butterfly bush |
Low |
| Evergreen
trees |
| Arbor-vitae |
High |
| Austrian pine |
High |
| Juniper/cedar |
High |
| Piñon pine |
High |
| Scots pine |
Moderate |
| Blue spruce |
Low |
| Eastern white pine |
Low |
| Ponderosa pine |
Low |
| White (concolor) fir |
Low |
| Evergreen
shrubs |
| Juniper |
High |
| Pyracantha (firethorn) |
High |
| Mugo pine |
Moderate |
| Oregon grape (grapeholly) |
Moderate |
Tips for Keeping Trees and Shrubs
Healthy When Using Recycled Water
|
Be aware of soil quality and drainage.
Soil quality
and drainage can influence plant health when using recycled water. Heavy
soils, poor drainage and compaction can create conditions that cause an
accumulation of salts. Because of this, sandy soil with good drainage is
better than clay soil with poor drainage. The best way to eliminate high
salt levels is leaching, which requires adequate irrigation and good
drainage or percolation rates. Aerating the soil on a regular basis is
one practice that will help increase and maintain drainage in the root
zone of plants.
|
|
Establish a systematic plant health-care program.
Plants that
are properly planted, pruned, fertilized and managed for insect and
disease control will grow better and stronger using any water supply,
especially recycled. A few excellent sources of information about plant
health care are: 1) Specifications Handbook of the Associated Landscape
Contractors of Colorado, 2) A Guide to the Plant Health Care
Management System, and 3) Plant Health Care for Woody Ornamentals. The
latter two are available from the International Society of
Arboriculture, Rocky Mountain Chapter, Denver. Also, there is
information available from Colorado State University Cooperative
Extension offices.
|
|
Be aware of soil pH.
Most native
soils in the Denver area have a basic or alkaline pH, i.e., greater than
7.0. Most trees and shrubs tolerate a relatively wide range in soil pH.
As the soil pH rises much above 7.0, however, some plants develop
deficiencies in elements such as iron and manganese, causing foliage to
turn yellow. Soil pH can be lowered by periodically applying sulfur
above that provided by recycled water. Or, individual plants can be
treated with iron or manganese to alleviate the problem and improve
health. |
Test water and soil.
Denver Water
will keep you updated regarding the quality of its recycled water by
posting results of periodic water quality tests on the Denver Water web
site at www.denverwater.org. If you feel you are having any problems,
soil testing can determine levels of soluble salts, bicarbonates, pH,
and other constituents discussed above. Some landscape managers may
choose to test soil on a yearly basis to form a foundation for soil
quality. Soil samples can be sent to a Colorado State University
Cooperative Extension office, Colorado State University directly, or can
be processed through a private soil testing laboratory.
|
Evaluate
irrigation methods.
Your
irrigation methods can cause an increase in a plant's absorption of
salts. Absorption of elements such as chloride and sodium through leaves
can cause injury
to some species of plants, especially when evapotranspiration rates are
high. In some cases, a greater accumulation of chloride and sodium can
occur through leaves than by absorption through roots. This can be
minimized by sprinkling during the evening and night. In addition,
redirecting sprinkler heads to avoid or minimize water directly spraying
the plants will help. Other techniques to minimize problems with water
spraying plants are to use low-volume heads, and adjust the spray angle
or arc.
|
Tips
for Selecting New Trees & Shrubs
When Using Recycled Water
|
Select
high-quality plants from the nursery or supplier.
Plants that
are grown properly and are free of insects, diseases and wounds will be
healthier. Healthy plants can withstand stresses including those of soil
and water quality, related to planting and establish-ment, much better
than unhealthy or improperly grown plants. Starting out with
high-quality plants can make a big difference.
|
|
Select
plants that are known to be moderately or highly tolerant of soil and
water salinity.
The
anticipated salinity of Denver Water's recycled water is low enough to
never be a problem for trees and shrubs with moderate to high salt
tolerance. See the plant list provided in this brochure for some
suggested plant materials.
|
|
Recycled
water is an abundant, cost-effective source of water for irrigating
parks, golf courses and commercial sites. Its impact on new
and established trees and shrubs will be negligible if proper planning
and management techniques are implemented.
As a prudent practice, landscape architects, park and golf course
superintendents and other landscape professionals should be aware of
certain factors when using recycled water. Factors such as physical
conditions of the soil, salt tolerance of plant species, nature of
planting sites and plant health care practices should be considered when
making decisions related to planning and managing landscapes irrigated
with recycled water.
|
|
Additional
Resources
Matheny,
N. & J.R. Clark. 1998. "Managing Landscapes Using Recycled Water."
The Landscape Below Ground II. D. Neely & G. Watson, Eds.
International Society of Arboriculture, Champaign, Ill.
United States Golf Association. 1994. Wastewater Reuse for Golf Course
Irrigation. Lewis Publisher, Boca Raton, Fla.
|
 |